Changes in the Newsroom

The steep and continuous decline of high margin print advertising has led to significant financial challenges for most newspapers which are cutting costs and trying to find new revenue sources.

There should be a reduction in duplicative layers of article editing, and visual experts must play a primary role in covering some stories. It means more visual journalism. There should be focus on diversity within the manpower so as to reflect the audiences they seek. There is too much duplicative and low-value line editing. If this is removed, there will be reductions in editorial manpower. In print production, there is multi-layered editing in the newsrooms.

A typical newsroom for digital media is a lean structure. It is a smaller and more focused newsroom. Print media must reconfigure its newsroom accordingly.

What is OTT ?

Internet video service is called  ‘over-the-top’ because it does not ride on traditional broadcasting or single telecom networks. Thanks to net neutrality, OTT video does not require affiliation with any operator.

Types of OTT Platforms

  • YouTube is an ad-funded and user generated OTT platform, which offers video-on-demand.
  • Viacom’s Voot, Jio Play ( from Reliance Jio ), TVF Play, OZee TV etc. operate in the ad-led video-on-demand space.
  • Hotstar, Sony Liv, Ditto TV, Viu, ErosNow operate on a freemium model, where some content is ad-led ( free ) while some is subscription-led.
  • Netflix and Amazon Prime are subscription-led offerings.

 

Challenges While Using Digital Media

Digital budgets are increasing. Along with it, there is the challenge for advertisers to convey a unified single message across the media. Besides, in multi-media world, ad spends are optimised by combining digital with other media, say print and TV. This true for both the digital and not-digital-only brands. Though digital targeting is very precise, there are many shades of grey here. The medium in India is still evolving. According to Kantar Millward Brown, social media drives better reach and brand impact among Gen Z  consumers ( people between 16-19 years of age ). Online videos work well for Gen Z and Gen Y consumers. Gen Y consumers are between 20-34 years of age. Online videos have lower impact on Gen X or those in the age group of 35-45 years. The younger the target audience, the greater are the chances of success of the digital medium. However, Gen Z tends to avoid ads the highest.

According to industry estimates, 30 per cent of India’s internet users have ad blockers, as against 28 per cent in China, 15 per cent in Europe and 10 per cent in the US.

Brands have to devise a strategy of both reaching the viewers, and getting viewed by them. This puzzle must be cracked.

Ads Next to Offensive Content

Advertisers are now concerned about their ads appearing alongside offensive content on YouTube. The Times, a London-based newspaper ran a story in mid-March, 2017 about YouTube hate preachers sharing screens with household brand names. Ads are bought programmatically, that is automatically using algorithms. This technique allows brands to follow internet users wherever they spend time and direct ads specifically at them. Such targeted ads are okay, but should not neglect what content the ads appear next to. So far there is no filtering or blocking of inappropriate content on behalf of advertisers, though the technology to do so is available with third party firms such as Integral Ad Science. Advertisers can monitor ad placement, and there are tools for it. Organisations can choose key words so that they can stay away from certain contents. However, very few advertisers use such tools. In future, more advertisers may resort to such solutions.

Print Media: A Wake Up Call

Abroad, we have seen a decline of the print media owing to the emergence of the digital media. Media there was costly, bulky and was to be picked up from a news-stand as there was no home delivery. India has more than 895 million literate people, and there are only 301 million people who read a publication. Thus one can see the potential for growth. Print media here is aspirational. Written word has the respect. There is this facility of home delivery. Though India’s print media has digital presence, the bulk of its revenues come from newspapers and magazines.

Still, there is slow down in the growth rate of print media in India. Hindustan Times has closed down its Kolkata, Bhopal and Ranchi editions. Many papers are pruning their print runs. There is less recruitment and there is cost cutting. What is seen in the newsrooms of English papers is likely to spread to the vernacular papers. Though print remains the most profitable media segment, it has been losing share. Its share has fallen down from 31 per cent ( 2005 ) to 24 per cent ( 2015 ). Maybe, this slow down will compel the print media to diversify into digital and other formats seriously. India is the one of the last bastions of print media. Even here major national dailies are shutting editions, laying off staff, cutting costs and freezing expansions and investments.

Print media is the only industry in the private sector where government- appointed wage board fixes wages. The recent recommendation has bled a number of print companies to the point of sickness. At least non-journalist staff must be removed from its ambit. The very concept of print journalist no longer exists as journalists have become platform-agnostic, moving from filing for online to writing for print to appearing on TV, all in the course of a single workday.

Under the new GST regime, newspapers must be ensured of zero rating.

The main source of revenue of the print media is advertising. It has shown little growth in the last few years — 4 to 6 per cent as compared to TV’s 15 to 18 per cent and digital’s 35-40 per cent.

There is a sharp increase in overhead costs. The cost of newsprint has increased, especially the imported variety.

Despite all this, Indian newspapers have kept cover prices among the lowest in the world — Rs 3 to Rs. 5 per copy on an average so as to keep them affordable.

Media in general and newspapers in particular are at an inflection point today.

Header Bidding

Header bidding has been integrated by Facebook on its platform. It allows mobile web publishers to collect bids and then select the highest offer. It improves upon the original programmatic auctions. Due to advance bidding technology, publishers can make more money and earn up to 10-30 per cent more revenues than programmatic advertising. Obviously, the cost of buying ads on the mobile web are set to go up.

Google’s Doubleclick has already adopted header bidding. Nearly 70 per cent of all publishers now use header bidding. It is a means to optimise yield, cut down on passbacks, increase transparency of inventory value. Doubleclick also eliminates Google’s favouritism for its for its own ad exchange AdX. Advertisers are given opportunity to bid on all available inventory and not just remnant inventory.