NFTs and Art

American artist Mike Winklemann, also known as Beeple, was auctioned as NFT on March 11, 2021, and was sold for $69 million. According to the auction house, he earned the sobriquet of the top three most valuable living artists, the other two being Jeff Koons and David Hockney. Beeple’s work — Everydays: The First 5000 Days — broke the world record of the most expensive NFT ever sold. It paved the way the global collectibles will be traded or acquired in time to come.

NFT democratises art. Anybody can download the art, but the token belongs to only one person. It is a technological innovation.

Digital art has been around for years. It is now that an effective monetisation is possible of such art. Sotheby’s introduced sales of NFTs at the beginning of this decade, and it has witnessed impressive sales.

It should be noted that digital art and NFTs are not superior to traditional art. They are different. Many traditional artists are now creating NFTs. It is an opportunity. NFTs empower artists and protect their ownership, and make a viable secondary market for digital art. While creating NFTs, artists can frame rules regarding licensing, royalties and profit sharing.

Many NFTs are minted so that the artist receives a percentage of the sale, each time it is sold.

At Sotheby’s, NFTs can be attached to physical objects such as traditional paintings to enhance the transfer and proof of ownership and secure the authentication process of physical works.

Every transfer or purchase of an NFT is recorded; it has also access to documentation of ownership history which is non-alterable.

It is necessary to monitor the transactions continuously, and take advantage of the time stamped for the transaction in future.

The creators benefit from NFT accounting. On an asset being sold, the original creator gets a percentage of the sale. The platform gets a small percentage and the current owner gets the remaining revenue. The whole thing has a potential for continuous revenue as the digital assets are bought and sold over time.

NFTs are not governed by any specific regulation in India. Maybe, Indian Contract Act, Securities Contract Regulation Act can govern them. It is a high-risk asset, and the person who acquires it must have high risk tolerance. NFTs could also be treated as commodities.

Madhushala (Hindi) NFT

Rhiti Entertainment runs as its part BeyondLife.club, a curated NFT platform. On November 3, 2021, it revealed most awaited NFT auction of Dr. Harivansh Rai Bachchan’s Madhushala (Hindi) NFT. It surged 1500 per cent as compared to its base price and is currently being sold for close to $480000 ( Rs.3.57crore). Madhushala (English) too attracted huge bids and is currently being bidded for $276000. You can keep your favourite author’s memorabilia or signature for times to come after paying the price. Madhushala has seen a phenomenal response, and so also the other Bachchan NFTs. Rhiti would like to launch NFTs of other stars too.

NFT Mystery

Non-fungible tokens or NFTs have taken the financial world by storm. Essentially, an NFT is a piece of code (written on a blockchain). This code is associated with something — usually digital or collectible. It could be a photo, music, artwork, a screenshot of Facebook page or even a tweet. As this something is digital, it is easily reproducible.

Imagine somebody creating a digital art work or music or something else. It is then associated with an NFT. A dog is being bathed by a Hollywood heroine . Or this is the first Facebook posting by Zuckerberg who founded Facebook. The next step is to sell the NFT, mostly in cryptocurrency, which too is recorded on a blockchain. NFT and crypto transaction blockchains are not necessarily the same.

The NFT associated with blockchain entry is unique. It can be sold. Every time it is sold, there will be a blockchain entry of the transaction.

People are ready to pay huge sums currently for the rights of owing blockchain entries. An NFT is thus basically worth whatever people are willing to pay. Will an NFT appreciate in value? Or is it just a passing fade?

Is NFT a work of art? If it is, it differs from physical paintings of M.F. Husain. Digital art is easily reproducible. Is it a financial derivative, an option? An option has an underlying asset, say shares, with agreed valuation. An NFTs underlying is indistinguishable from any digital copy.

We are reminded of Tulip mania in the 17th century. People bought tulip bulbs in anticipation of price rise. They paid extravagant prices in anticipation and appeared foolish. They feared that a greater fool may come along and pay even a higher price. It is pure speculation.

Snafu : AI-backed Music Label

Snafu uses artificial intelligence (AI) to sift through several thousand songs each week. It uses a combination of neural networks for sentiment analysis, collaborative filtering and some other deep learning architecture. It has its offices in Los Angeles, Mumbai and Bogota. It was started in March, 2018 and has signed 50 artists across the globe. Raghav Meattle, a Mumbai-based singer-songwriter and Armaan Malik have been signed by Snafu.

It focuses on unreleased music. It identifies talents and tries to market them. An artiste finds the song — collaborator process is slow and random. They blur everything and create a community of artistes and collaborators.

A song writer may have a repertoire of songs. It is all put on a cloud. They would like to match the right song with the right artiste with the help of AI.

Finance is an issue in emerging markets such as India. They will forcast the streaming potential of a song based on projected earning. That will facilitate the financing decision.

Snafu tries to identify rough diamonds from millions of songs. AI has to find a needle from a haystack. They could source talents from social media. A song’s growth is monitored. Its buzz is examined. Its structure is studied. Algorithm ranks the songs on these parameters, and facilitates the prediction of its success.

Snafu is taking on well-established music companies. Another issue — the shift from long-form of music to short form music listening. Hits emerge from short reels.

Other companies such as Musilo, Singapore has developed Hit Potential Algorithm. Warner Music Group bring music piece and an unsigned talent together by using a repertoire tool called Sodatone.

Shoppable Video : YouTube

In November 2021, YouTube will host weeklong livestreaming event (Holiday Stream and Shop). Here social media will market their own products directly. They will put shoppable videos — whereby YouTube becomes a shopping destination. It will set up a new division focused on shopping. To begin with, there were cable networks by showing online video. They floundered along the way. China, however, made e-commerce to flourish on social media. YouTube would like to replicate the Chinese experiment. YouTube rivals such as Facebook, TikTok and Snapchat too are trying, to crack this market. YouTube has additional benefit — Google’s online retail partnerships with Shopify, Square and others. It connects YouTube to merchants and delivery systems. YouTube wants to leverage its stars too.

Open Source

Open source is coming centre stage. Many freeware are as capable and dynamic as the paid ones. There are several key sectors of economy where open source is being used.

Open source reduces costs. There are no vendor lock-ins. The code can be examined for privacy issues. Bugs can be detected. There is transparency and accountability. Co-win and Arogyasetu are built as open source digital platforms.

The open source developing community contribute valuable inputs. Most of India’s internet runs on FOSS or free open source software. The government encourages digital adoption through open source programmes.

Open source systems represent what internet truly meant to represent — democratisation of technology. Currently, we use Web 2, and with it the proprietary IP too flourished since the late 1990s. However, Web 3 promises decentralised networks and open source systems. There are open source substitutes for CRM, banking solutions, ERP and IoT.

There is misunderstanding that open source developers are not compensated for their contribution. That dilutes the quality of the work. This is not true. Open source developers are allocated finance while they contribute to open source projects. They in fact become the face of the system. The others become marketers.

There would be a cultural shift once open source takes centre stage. There would be decentralised networks and autonomous organisations operating over them. Web 3 will arrive.

There is a misconception that FOSS is less secure than proprietary software. There is lack of customisation too. People prefer to deal with known vendors, rather than disperse community of developers.

App Store Monopoly

Most of the apps are downloaded from Google Play and Apple Stores who earn a sizeable cut, running into billions of dollars. That is the sheer dominance of app platforms of the two tech giants. It takes away the earnings of the app developers or vendors by forcing them to use the payment system of the tech giants. Google and Apple too can have app offerings which compete with others in some areas. South Korea legislated to prevent the usage of their payment systems.

Google did some damage control by slashing its commissions on subscriptions-based apps to 15 per cent, instead of 30 per cent for the first year. Commission rates could come down to 10 per cent for apps that participate in its Play Media Experience programme. Non-Google, non-Apple payment systems, however, charge just 1-2 per cent commission.

App startups resist the monopolistic tendency. However, jurisdictions like Europe allow downloading apps from internet, outside the app stores — this is called side-loading. Microsoft has kept low commission rates — just 5 per cent.

Dictating terms to app makers by the stores has gate-keeping effect. It becomes a matter of survival for small developers.

App stores should follow the doctrine of fairness, rather than the benevolence shown by slashing the rates. The commission should be left to the market forces.

India can think of suitable legislative measures to benefit both the stores and developers. It should address the anti-competitive practices and focus on user privacy.

Vape to Quit Smoking

E-cigarettes are controversial. These can be used to quit smoking or could further aggravate addiction. The UK could be the first country in the world to opt for vaping to quit smoking. Thus e-cigarettes could be used as medicines. Other countries too are watching this experiment closely. Could prescription vaping have desirable impact on smokers? Could it have undesirable consequences?

Smoking is injurious to health. E-cigarettes are considered less harmful than smoking tobacco. If these are made available through NHS, they will help smokers to quit the habit. The cost of smoking is much higher than the cost of vaping.

Open : New Age Neo-bank

A neo-bank is a non-bank which offers banking services to its customers. In fact, it is a financial technology firm. It can offer full-fledged services that a bank offers. A neo-bank has no banking license. However, they parther with a licensed bank. Digital lenders offer only lending services.

Internationally, Monzo and Revolut started as non-licensed firms, and tied up with banks. They thus could offer savings accounts to their customers.

Neo-banks can do or not do lending. There are some fintechs that concentrate only on lending.

Open has emerged as a small and medium enterprise focused neo-banking platform. It offers current account to SMEs in tie up with a bank. They have a dashboard with tools for small business to automate their finances. Such tools are built-in invoicing, built-in pay-roll, built-in accounting and regulatory filings.

Open lends on the basis of credit scores or conventional bank statements.

Open also collects, sends, and receives payments internationally. They have built a blockchain-based cross -border payments system.

Metaverses : Evolution

As we know, the term metaverse was derived from the 1992 novel, Snow Crash by Neal Stephenson. In 1991, Tim Berners — Lee Invented HTML or Hyper Text Mark-Up Language which laid the foundation of the World Wide Web. In this novel, Stephenson imagined a world with MNCs and AR which he called the metaverse. This concept of metaverse has been adopted by the tech community. In fact, the metaverse will consist of multiple metaverses or spaces, seamlessly blending the physical reality into augmented reality (AR) and virtual reality (VR). It could be seen as an extension of the social media. It will attract huge investment for its development and marketing.

The hardware that will be used in meta will be VR helmets, and platforms like Horizons. Microsoft is developing software, avatars and productivity tools. Roblox, a gaming platform, is developing meta-gaming tools. Tinder may introduce meta-sexuality nuances. Electronic Arts may create metaverses centred on its games. Each organisation will contribute to the development of metaverses in its own way. It is difficult to figure industry standard at this stage.

What for these platforms be used? What is going to be the revenue model? These are issues difficult to answer now. Of course, gaming is one of the possibilities. There could be enhanced entertainment options. There could be simulations of real environment, providing touch-and-feel experience. After a technology develops, there could be unimaginable ways of using it.